Hardik Pandya made a much-anticipated return to Mumbai Indians in the Indian Premier League 2024 (IPL) season, rejoining the franchise that had been his home for several years before leading Gujarat Titans (GT) to a title triumph in 2022. His comeback t MI as captain brought significant expectations, considering his success as a leader with Gujarat. However, the 2024 season proved to be a challenging one for both Pandya and MI. The team struggled with consistency and finished outside the playoff positions and along with this the internal structure of the team appeared unsettled at times.

Hardik Pandya’s underwhelming performance for Mumbai Indians in IPL 2024

In IPL 2024, Hardik’s performance with the bat was disappointing, as he managed only 216 runs in 14 matches, with a highest score of 46 and an average of 18.00. His strike rate of 143.05 indicates a lack of substantial contributions, with no half-centuries to his name. In the field, he took just four catches, highlighting a modest impact on the game. With the ball, Pandya claimed 11 wickets, averaging 35.18, but his economy rate of 10.75 raised concerns about his consistency. His best bowling figures of 3/31 showed flashes of his potential, yet the overall season reflected a struggle to meet expectations.

Leadership dilemma: Should Mumbai Indians stick with Hardik?

The team’s struggles in 2024 have sparked discussions about whether MI should explore a leadership change. Some rumours suggest that the franchise may consider handing back the captaincy to Rohit Sharma, the most successful IPL captain, or potentially try a fresh approach with Suryakumar Yadav, known for his dynamic batting and leadership potential.

Jasprit Bumrah, respected for his calmness under pressure, is another potential candidate.

Nevertheless, Pandya’s leadership skills are undeniable, as shown by his IPL 2022 triumph with GT. While the 2024 season didn’t go as planned for MI, the decision to replace Pandya would need to consider his potential to lead in the long term, especially as he continues to develop his captaincy experience.

Also READ: 5 teams that can target Joe Root at the IPL 2025 mega auction

3 important reasons why Hardik should remain Mumbai Indians captain in IPL 2025:

1. Proven Leadership with Multiple IPL Title-Winning Experience

Hardik has already demonstrated his tactical brilliance and leadership abilities, notably during his time with GT. In 2022, Pandya led the newly formed franchise to an IPL title in their debut season, an achievement that speaks volumes about his ability to manage a team effectively under pressure. Under his captaincy, GT not only won 10 out of 14 league games but also dominated the playoffs.

In 2023, Pandya’s leadership took GT to the finals again, cementing his place as one of the most successful captains in recent years. His calm demeanor on the field, coupled with an astute understanding of the game, helped GT secure 10 wins in 14 matches once more, even though they finished as runners-up.

Notably, Pandya made several smart captaincy decisions, such as field placements and bowling rotations, which helped Gujarat’s bowlers perform at critical junctures of the game. His success as a leader, evidenced by back-to-back finals and playoff appearances, underscores why Mumbai Indians would benefit from reinstating Pandya as their captain. His ability to manage high-pressure situations, whether during tight chases or crucial death overs, makes him an invaluable leader.

2. Consistent All-Round Contributions Across Recent Seasons

Hardik’s all-round performance has been a vital asset, contributing both with the bat and ball. In the 2022 IPL season, he amassed 487 runs at a solid average of 44.27 and a healthy strike rate of 131.27. His ability to score runs when the team needed them most, especially under pressure, was crucial to Gujarat’s success. Pandya also registered 4 half-centuries, showing his adaptability to anchor innings or accelerate when needed.

In 2023, Pandya’s batting form remained solid, as he tallied 346runs at an average of 31.45 and an enhanced strike rate of 136.75, proving his versatility and dominance in the middle order. His batting contributions were often game-changing, as he played pivotal roles in finishing matches for GT. With the ball, he remained a vital cog in Gujarat’s bowling attack, picking up 8wickets in 2022 and 3 wickets in 2023 at critical junctures and maintaining an economy rate around 9.00 in both seasons. His bowling, often utilized in crunch moments, allowed GT to break partnerships and keep the opposition in check.

Pandya’s dual role as a reliable all-rounder and captain, excelling in both departments, makes him a complete package for leadership. His consistency and ability to turn matches around with either bat or ball is a quality that Mumbai Indians would greatly benefit from.

3. Strong Mumbai Indians Legacy and Deep IPL Experience

Before his stint with GT, Pandya had already carved out an illustrious career with  MI, where he played a key role in their dominance from 2015 to 2021. During this period, Pandya was an essential part of MI’s core, contributing to their four IPL title wins. In those six seasons, Pandya accumulated 1476 runs at an explosive strike rate of 153.95, consistently finishing games for MI with his aggressive hitting down the order. His ability to clear boundaries at will made him one of the most dangerous lower-order batter in the league.

With the ball, Pandya took 42 wickets for MI, often stepping up during critical phases of the game, whether it was in the middle overs or during the death. His experience with Mumbai Indians, coupled with his proven track record as a match-winner, suggests that he could easily transition back into the MI setup as a leader. His knowledge of the MI culture and winning mindset is an asset that few players can match.

Pandya’s recent captaincy success with GT has only further developed his game awareness, leadership qualities, and man-management skills, making him an even stronger candidate to lead MI in the future. The familiarity with MI’s setup, combined with his newfound leadership experience, would allow Pandya to guide the team back to IPL glory with a fresh perspective and aggressive leadership style.

Also READ: 3 reasons why Joe Root is a must-buy at the IPL 2025 auction

For latest cricket news & updates, visit CricketTimes.com.